You are here: Home / Groups / Earths Interior / Wiki / CitcomS / Benchmarks / Compare
  • Discoverability Visible
  • Join Policy Invite Only
  • Created 30 Dec 2020

Benchmarks

Version 1
by (unknown)
Version 2
by (unknown)

Deletions or items before changed

Additions or items after changed

1 == Benchmarks ==
2 Reproducing Results from the Zhong et. al. paper using !CitcomS 3.2.0
3 The following plots are from data generated by !CitcomS 3.2.0 on Stampede. Figure numbers correspond to Zhong et al.
4
5 Figure 5
6 ||[[Image(figure_5_a.png)]] ||[[Image(figure_5_b.png)]]||[[Image(figure_5_c.png)]] ||
7
8 Figure 7(a)
9 [[Image(figure_7_a.png)]]
10
11 ==== Comparison of Values from Table 6 of the Zhong et. al. paper ====
12 Mean and standard deviations () are computed over the t1,t2 ] interval
13
14 '''A1'''
15 ||'''Benchmark'''||'''t1''' ||'''t2''' ||'''< V_rms >''' ||'''< Nu_ t>''' ||'''< T >'''||
16 ||A1 (Zhong et. al.) ||0.7 ||1.0 ||32.66 (6e-4) ||3.5126 (2e-4) ||0.2171 (2e-5)||
17 ||A1 (!CitcomS 3.2.0) ||0.7 ||1.0 ||32.68 (4e-3) ||3.5263 (4e-4) ||0.2187 (6e-5)||
18 ||A1 (Gaia) ||? ||1.0 ||32.65 ||3.5096 ||0.2160||
19
20 '''A2'''
21 ||'''Benchmark''' ||'''t1''' ||'''t2''' ||'''< V_rms >''' ||'''< Nu_t >''' ||'''< T >'''||
22 ||A2 (Zhong et. al.) ||1.0 ||1.3 ||27.36 (1e-4) ||3.2674 (1e-5) ||0.2360 (3e-7)||
23 ||A2 (!CitcomS 3.2.0) ||1.0 ||1.3 ||27.33 (6e-3) ||3.2831 (1e-3) ||0.2381 (1e-4)||
24 ||A2 (Gaia) ||? ||1.0 ||27.19 ||3.2550 ||0.2351||
25
26 '''A3'''
27 ||'''Benchmark''' ||'''t1''' ||'''t2''' ||'''< V_rms >''' ||'''< Nu_t >''' ||'''< T >'''||
28 ||A3 (Zhong et. al.) ||0.6 ||0.9 ||25.85 (1e-3) ||3.1724 (3e-4) ||0.2432 (3e-5)||
29 ||A3 (!CitcomS 3.2.0) ||0.6 ||0.9 ||25.77 (1e-3) ||3.1768 (3e-4) ||0.2447 (3e-5)||
30 ||A3 (Gaia) ||? ||1.0 ||25.65 ||3.1601 ||0.2427||
31
32 '''A4'''
33 ||'''Benchmark''' ||'''t1''' ||'''t2''' ||'''< V_rms >''' ||'''< Nu_t >''' ||'''< T >'''||
34 ||A4 (Zhong et. al.) ||1.5 ||2.0 ||23.11 (3e-4) ||2.9354 (4e-5) ||0.2653 (2e-6)||
35 ||A4 (!CitcomS 3.2.0) ||1.5 ||2.0 ||23.01 (5e-3) ||2.9175 (1e-3) ||0.2659 (2e-5)||
36 ||A4 (Gaia) ||? ||1.0 ||22.90 ||2.9259 ||0.2663||
37
38 '''A5'''
39 ||'''Benchmark''' ||'''t1''' ||'''t2''' ||'''< V_rms >''' ||'''< Nu_t >''' ||'''< T >'''||
40 ||A5 (Zhong et. al.) ||1.0 ||1.5 ||22.90 (3e-3) ||2.5468 (5e-4) ||0.3124 (1e-5)||
41 ||A5 (!CitcomS 3.2.0) ||1.0 ||1.5 ||22.86 (3e-2) ||2.5380 (7e-4) ||0.3126 (7e-5)||
42 ||A5 (Gaia) ||? ||1.0 ||22.77 ||2.5386 ||0.3152||
43
44 '''A7'''
45 ||'''Benchmark''' ||'''t1''' ||'''t2''' ||'''< V_rms>''' ||'''< Nu_t >''' ||'''< T >'''||
46 ||A7 (Zhong et. al.) ||1.2 ||1.7 ||50.21 (8e-3) ||2.7382 (5e-4) ||0.5039 (1e-4)||
47 ||A7 (!CitcomS 3.2.0) ||1.2 ||1.7 ||11.09 (5e-2) ||1.8972 (5e-3) ||0.3870 (3e-4)||
48 ||A7 (Gaia) ||? ||5.0 ||46.83 ||2.4917 ||0.4529||
49
50 '''A8'''
51 ||'''Benchmark''' ||'''t1''' ||'''t2''' ||'''< V_rms >''' ||'''< Nu_t >''' ||'''< T >'''||
52 ||A8 (Zhong et. al.) ||0.8 ||1.0 ||87.27 (4e-2) ||3.0317 (2.8e-3) ||0.5461 (1e-4)||
53 ||A8 (!CitcomS 3.2.0) ||0.8 ||1.0 ||88.01 (2e-2) ||3.0889 (1e-3) ||0.5530 (1e-4)||
54 ||A8 (Gaia) ||? ||4.1 ||83.35 ||3.1328 ||0.5531||
55
56
57
58
59 ==== Comparison of Values from Table 7 of the Zhong et. al. paper. [[br]] ====
60 Mean and standard deviations () are computed over the t1,t2 ] interval
61
62 '''B1'''
63 ||'''Benchmark''' ||'''t1''' ||'''t2''' ||'''< V_rms >''' ||'''< Nu_t >''' ||'''< T>'''||
64 ||B1 (Zhong et. al.) ||1.2 ||1.7 ||31.09 (1e-4) ||3.6254 (1e-5) ||0.2176 (6e-7)||
65 ||B1 (!CitcomS 3.2.0) ||1.2 ||1.7 ||31.02 (1e-14) ||3.6212 (2e-6) ||0.2171 (3e-16)||
66
67 '''B2'''
68 ||'''Benchmark''' ||'''t1''' ||'''t2''' ||'''< V_rms >''' ||'''< Nu_t >''' ||'''< T >'''||
69 ||B2 (Zhong et. al.) ||0.8 ||1.1 ||25.13 (7e-5) ||3.3721 (2e-5) ||0.2527 (2e-6)||
70 ||B2 (!CitcomS 3.2.0) ||0.8 ||1.1 ||25.09 (2e-4) ||3.3677 (2e-5) ||0.2525 (5e-6)||
71
72 '''B3'''
73 ||'''Benchmark''' ||'''t1''' ||'''t2''' ||'''< V_rms >''' ||'''< Nu_t >''' ||'''< T >'''||
74 ||B3 (Zhong et. al.) ||0.8 ||1.2 ||24.35 (8e-5) ||3.3162 (2e-5) ||0.2587 (2e-6)||
75 ||B3 (!CitcomS 3.2.0) ||0.8 ||1.2 ||24.32 (5e-5) ||3.3122 (2e-5) ||0.2586 (3e-6)||
76
77 '''B4'''
78 ||'''Benchmark''' ||'''t1''' ||'''t2''' ||'''< V_rms >''' ||'''< Nu_t >''' ||'''< T >''' ||
79 ||B4 (Zhong et. al.) ||1.0 ||1.3 ||22.49 (2e-5) ||3.1278 (6e-6) ||0.2797 (4e-7)||
80 ||B4 (!CitcomS 3.2.0) ||1.0 ||1.3 ||22.47 (3e-14) ||3.1233 (4e-6) ||0.2797 (1e-16)||
81
82 ==== Benchmarking Papers ====
83 [http://dx.doi.org/10.1029/2008GC002048 Zhong et. al. (2008)]
84
85 ==== Configuration files used for the Benchmarks ====
86 -
[/projects/citcoms/files/download?asset=a-benchmarks.tgz a-benchmarks.tgz]
+
[[File(a-benchmarks.tgz)]]